Amy Spitalnick, a prominent figure in progressive Jewish advocacy is a frequent speaker at Jewish Organizations across the United States. Known for her affiliations with left-wing politicians and organizations, Spitalnick’s role as the CEO of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA) has drawn both praise and criticism.
Controversy Surrounding AOC and AIPAC
Recently, Spitalnick was thrust into a national conversation following Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s (AOC) criticism of the pro-Israel group AIPAC. AOC labeled AIPAC as a “special interest group pushing a wildly unpopular agenda.” Critics argue this echoed longstanding antisemitic tropes regarding Jewish influence. Rather than condemning the remarks, Spitalnick partially agreed with AOC, citing AIPAC’s dangers. This stance ignited backlash across social media, with voices like Joel Petlin and Professor David E. Bernstein urging Spitalnick to unequivocally denounce AOC’s rhetoric.
Progressive Agenda or Jewish Advocacy?
Spitalnick’s has been criticized for prioritizing progressive politics over Jewish communal concerns. Her appearance with controversial figures like Reverend Al Sharpton, whose history includes inflammatory remarks during the 1991 Crown Heights riots. Critics argue that her platform amplifies left-wing alliances at the expense of addressing pressing Jewish issues, such as rising antisemitism.
Intersectionality and DEI: A Divisive Approach
A recurring theme in Spitalnick’s advocacy is her emphasis on intersectionality—linking antisemitism with broader forms of hate, such as racism and Islamophobia. While this approach aims to build coalitions, some Jewish leaders argue it diminishes the unique challenges faced by Jewish communities.
Spitalnick’s critique of Jews opposing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs as advancing an “extremist agenda” has drawn ire, with many questioning whether this rhetoric fosters division rather than unity.
Spitalnick’s 67-page “Report on Democracy” outlines her vision of an “inclusive, multiracial democracy” but has been criticized for aligning closely with progressive partisan goals. The report’s language, described as vague and formulaic, conflates Jewish safety with broader political agendas, alienating segments of the Jewish community who feel marginalized by such narratives. Her emphasis on intersectionality, progressive alliances will likely shape her legacy and the path forward for the organizations she represents.
